評論
打印
The old man would have had to hear the boy say, "I'm going to kill you," while the train was roaring by the old man's window. No, it was not possible that he could have heard it.
所以，當老人聽到那男孩說我要殺了你。”時列車正轟隆隆地駛過他的窗前，不，他不可能聽得到。
No. 3: Don't talk about matters of seconds! Nobody can be that accurate.
3號陪審員：這是在幾秒間發生的事情！沒人能夠那么精確。
No. 8: And I think a testimony that can put a boy in the chair should be that accurate!
8號陪審員：而我認為能將一個男孩送上電椅的證詞就應該那么精確！
No. 5: (Whispers to No. 6) I don't think he could have heard it.
5號陪審員：（低聲對6號說）我認為那個老頭聽不到。
No. 3: Why should he lie? What has he got to gain?
3號陪審員：那他為什么要說謊？他想得到什么？
No. 9: Attention, maybe. I looked at him for a very long time. It seemed that his jacket was split. I didn't notice that... I mean, to come into the court like that. He was a very old man with a torn jacket. He walked very slowly to the stand. He was dragging his left leg, and tried to hide it, because he was ashamed. This is a quiet, frightened, insignificant, old man who's been nothing all his life, who's never had any recognition, whose name never has appeared in the newspapers. Nobody knows him 75 years. Gentlemen, that's a very sad thing to be nothing. A Man like that needs to be recognized, to be listened to, to be quoted just once. Very important to him...
9號陪審員：或許是想引起人們的注意。我觀察了他很久。他的夾克衫好像都裂開了。我之前沒有注意到這一點……我是說，他是那樣走進法庭的。他老態龍鐘，穿著破舊的夾克衫。他慢慢走向證人席，努力拖著他的左腿，他竭力想掩飾這一缺陷，因為他對此感到羞愧。他是個沉默寡言、膽小如鼠、微不足道的人，一生無所作為。沒有人認識他，他的名字也從未在報紙上出現過。75年來誰都不知道他。先生們，無所作為確實是件很可悲的事情。像他這樣的人需要別人的認可、傾聽，需要別人引用他的話，哪怕只有一次，對他來說，都很重要……
No. 7: Are you trying to tell us that he lied just so he could be important once?
7號陪審員：你是想告訴我們他說謊只是為了得到一次重視嗎？
No. 9: No, he wouldn't really lie. But perhaps he made himself believe he heard those words and recognized the boy's voice.
9號陪審員：不，也許他不是真的說謊，但是，或許他讓自己相信他聽到了那些話，并且辨出了那孩子的聲音。
No. 10: That's the most fantastic story I've ever heard. How can you make up a thing like that? What do you know about it?
10號陪審員：這是我聽到的最離奇的故事了。你怎么會編出這么一個故事來呢？你怎么知道他是這么想的？
No. 9: (Low but firm) I speak from experience.
9號陪審員：（聲音很小但很堅定）我是經驗之談。
No. 7: What!
7號陪審員：什么？
No. 9: I've done it myself.
9號陪審員：我就這樣干過。
