Introduction: State my opinion
The hi-tech media should been provided by the public libraries.
Body: Ph 1 Making concession
Multimedia facilities are expensive.
Ph2 Reason one to support my opinion.
Hi-tech media can store information much longer than traditional means.
Ph3 Reason two to support my opinion
Visiting a library with multimedia access is much more interesting.
Conclusion: Restate my opinion
The investment is justified and should be encouraged.
從上述結構我們看出作者的觀點是支持提供高科技媒體,但這個論證過程非常全面,它先在論證的第一代就退一步承認其缺點,然后再就這一點進行反駁,這個段落就是讓步段,參考之前提供句型,得出這一段:Opponents of a high-tech library would argue that multimedia facilities are expensive. This may be true to some extent, because a DVD player is often more expensive than a bookshelf. However, with immense storage capacity, these new high-tech media can actually save the most valuable resource-space.
讓步段還可以運用到討論類另一種結構中,筆者謂之雙邊傾向論證。我們通過一個具體的實例來解釋這種論證結構以及讓步在其中的用法。
There are social, medical and technical problems associated with the use of mobile phones. What forms do they take? Do you agree that the problems outweigh the benefits of mobile phones?
老師建議此題一定要認真審題,因為這個問題模式對文章的結構有著直接的影響。它有兩問,第一問要回答手機的三個方面的問題,第二問優缺點討論,結合這兩問,得出文章結構如下:
Introduction: State my opinion
The problems of mobile phones far exceed the merits.
Body: Ph 1 the benefits brought about by mobiles (Making concession)
Convenient, functional
Ph2 the social, medial and technical problems of mobile phones
Conclusion: Restate my opinion
Although mobile phones have some benefits, the negative influences should not be overlooked.
看完結構,不難理解雙邊傾向的結構即兩個方面優點和缺點都提及,作者的觀點是傾向其中一方的,那么不同意的那一方的論證段就可以理解為讓步段。結合句式,我們可以寫一下讓步段的topic sentence:It is undeniable that mobile phones have facilitated our lives in many different ways. 接著可以列舉手機使用的幾個具體的優點。這種讓步和單邊論證讓步的區別是它可以不用直接在這個段落
后面反駁。
III 結語
讓步段在論證過程中有著相當廣泛的實戰意義,它可以幫助考生擴展文章的字數,達到要求,此外,它還能使得論證過程更加全面,希望為寫作取得高分有切實的幫助。